Citi/Chase Short Sale Case Study:
Property Location: Kirkland, WA - King County
1st Lender: Citi
2nd Lender: Chase
Hardship:
“We have had some setbacks in our lives over the past few years, that have resulted in our becoming delinquent on our mortgage for our home.
“Our sources of income are from my wife’s job as a mortgage representative and from mine as a financial analyst. My wife’s income was primarily derived from mortgages on the purchase of new and pre-owned homes; this activity has slowed to a crawl in the markets she’s been active in. Her income so far this year has only been about $8,000, a fraction of what she made prior to 2008. I am paid hourly, but this year due to a decline in overtime hours my wages are down by about 10%. The combined effect of this has resulted in a decline of over 50% in our income.
“In addition, my sister (who lived back East) was diagnosed with terminal lung cancer in the summer of 2009. She succumbed to the disease this year. Over the course of the 2nd half of 2009 and first 4 months of 2010 we incurred about $10,000 in out-of-pocket costs to help with her care.
“Unfortunately, the prospects for improvement in our income situation do not appear good.”
1st Loan Balance: $416,640
2nd Loan Balance: $184,240
Sales Price: $459,950
Approved Commissions: 6%
1st Loan Approved Net Proceeds: $395,352
2nd Loan Approved Net Proceeds: $6,000
Timeline:
On February 22, 2011, a signed offer to purchase the home for $430,000 was received. On March 4, the completed short sale package was submitted to both lenders. While this package was under review, on March 29, 2011, a higher offer to purchase the home for $449,950 was received. On April 8, Seattle Short Sales, Inc., resubmitted the short sale package to the lenders with the higher offer.
On April 12, Citi as 1st lender rejected the first offer, indicating that it was not enough to provide their investor’s (Fannie Mae’s) minimum approved net proceeds of $436,600 - which they indicated was “non-negotiable.” The Seattle Short Sales, Inc., replied to them, indicating that the case had already been resubmitted with the new, higher offer and requesting that they review it.
Then Citi’s negotiator indicated that their investor would actually consider minimum net proceeds less than $436,600 provided that the BPO (Broker’s Price Opinion) supports the high level of loss that the homeowner has incurred. They indicated that they would accept $394,000 if the loss was significant, and provided that the payout to the second lender was capped at $6,000. The Seattle Short Sales, Inc., case manager calculated that this would require a sales price increase of $10,000, and on April 12 contacted the listing agent to see if his buyers would agree to that.
The buyers agreed to the increased purchase price of $459,950 and the following day, on April 13, Citi as 1st lender issued their approval letter for the short sale, waiving the sellers of their obligation to pay back the $21,000 deficiency balance on the loan, for closing by May 13, 2011.
On April 27, Chase as 2nd lender issued their approval of the short sale, also for closing by May 13, and waiving the seller of their obligation to pay back the $178,000 deficiency balance owing on their loan.
However, the sellers had expected to have 30 days from issuance of the final approval letters before closing (as indicated on the PSA), and were not prepared to be moving out by May 13. They contacted the Seattle Short Sales, Inc., case manager in a panic, asking him to extend the closing date so they would have time to organize their move.
The Seattle Short Sales case manager managed to get extensions on both approvals, and the short sale closed on May 26.
Result:
The homeowners, who had suffered severe wage cuts and could no longer afford their home, were able to undertake a short sale and pay out both mortgages. Significantly, they were waived of having any future obligation to pay back the deficiency balances: $21,000 owing on the first mortgage and a hefty $178,000 on the second mortgage - allowing them to leave their financial troubles behind and start anew.
To download a copy of the short sale 1st approval letter, click here: http://seattleshortsales.com/LiteratureRetrieve.aspx?ID=85295
To download a copy of the short sale 2nd approval letter, click here: http://seattleshortsales.com/LiteratureRetrieve.aspx?ID=85296
If you are a homeowner, and would like to learn more about short selling your home, please go to: http://seattleshortsales.com/homeowners/
If you are a real estate agent, and would like to learn about our no-fee short sale service, please go to: http://seattleshortsales.com/agents/






Comments
Post has no comments.